Malaysia’s Ranking for Citation/Document in Scopus

Citation per document

1996- Rank 60

2010- Rank 88

2011- Rank 87

2012 – Rank 88

Source: Scimago Journal Ranking

Econometrics of israel-Palestinian Conflict

link for paper: Haushofer J, Biletzki A, Kanwisher N (2010). Both Sides Retaliate in the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict. PNAS 107, 17927-32.

Ending violent international conflicts requires understanding the causal factors that perpetuate them. In the Israeli–Palestinian conflict, Israelis and Palestinians each tend to see themselves as victims, engaging in violence only in response to attacks initiated by a fundamentally and implacably violent foe bent on their destruction. Econometric techniques allow us to empirically test the degree to which violence on each side occurs in response to aggression by the other side. Prior studies using these methods have argued that Israel reacts strongly to attacks by Palestinians, whereas Palestinian violence is random (i.e., not predicted by prior Israeli attacks). Here we replicate prior findings that Israeli killings of Palestinians increase after Palestinian killings of Israelis, but crucially show further that when nonlethal forms of violence are considered, and when a larger dataset is used, Palestinian violence also reveals a pattern of retaliation: (i) the firing of Palestinian rockets increases sharply after Israelis kill Palestinians, and (ii) the probability (although not the number) of killings of Israelis by Palestinians increases after killings of Palestinians by Israel. These findings suggest that Israeli military actions against Palestinians lead to escalation rather than incapacitation. Further, they refute the view that Palestinians are uncontingently violent, showing instead that a significant proportion of Palestinian violence occurs in response to Israeli behavior. Well-established cognitive biases may lead participants on each side of the conflict to underappreciate the degree to which the other side’s violence is retaliatory, and hence to systematically underestimate their own role in perpetuating the conflict.

Negative wage growth

Negative wage growth

KUALA LUMPUR (July 20, 2011): Wage increases in the country have been lagging behind rising prices of goods and services over the past few years, and this is fuelling a widening income disparity between the rich and poor, economists said.

And this high level of inequality is detrimental to future growth and if left unchecked, is a threat to the country’s aspiration to become a high-income nation.

“We have a negative income growth in a growing economy,” Institute of Strategic and International Studies (ISIS) senior analyst Muhammed Abdul Khalid said Wednesday in his presentation at a forum organised by Malaysia Rating Corp Bhd.

At the function, a book by MARC chief economist Nor Zahidi Alias, compiling his articles in the media, was also launched.

One reason often cited for this mismatch in salary increase and price hike is the oversupply of cheap labour in the country.

Muhammed said about 34% of the population earn less than RM700 a month. This means a third of the working population have an income below the official poverty line of RM720 a month.

According to Muhammed, the country’s gross domestic product (GDP) expanded at an average rate of 5.3% every year between 2000 and 2009. In the meantime, wages increased by 2.9%, which was slower than the annual inflation rate of 3.2%.

The government hoped to achieve a steady 6% annual growth and become a developed nation by 2020. A key target is to boost gross national income per capita (GNI) to US$15,000 from the current US$8,140 and qualify as a high-income nation.

This brings the question of whether the wealth is equally distributed.

Muhammed said a lot of the country’s wealth is concentrated in a small group of people, with 20% of the population owning 95% of the financial assets.

“The gap between the rural poor and urban rich is at its widest,” he said.

Muhammed also shared his view on the brain drain, which he said is a “normal thing” that is happening all over the world.

The concern for Malaysia, however, was that the outflow of talents was not being compensated by inflows, resulting in a shortage in certain professions.

The Long Divergence: How Islamic Law Held Back the Middle East, By Timur Kuran

“… This is a fresh and thought-provoking argument. But it is based on the assumption that Western financial institutions, and self-serving corporations, are the best possible model for development. Given the havoc that these institutions have caused in recent times, and the fact that injustice and obscene wealth is integral to their make-up, I think it is an assumption too far.

One also needs to consider why Islam insists on the egalitarian distribution of wealth and historically suppressed the emergence of monopoly capital. Perhaps it has something to do with a socially conscience vision of society that emphasises genuine equity and justice? Kuran’s thesis is contentious; but it does provide us with an incentive to reformulate Islamic law. It is an excellent starting-point for a debate long overdue.” Reviewed by Ziauddin Sardar

Reviewer:
Çizakça, Murat

Published by EH.NET (June 2011)

Timur Kuran, The Long Divergence: How Islamic Law Held Back the Middle East. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2011. xvi + 405 pp. $30 (hardcover), ISBN: 978-0-691-14756-7.

Reviewed for EH.Net by Murat Çizakça, INCEIF, Kuala Lumpur.

Timur Kuran is an avid reader of Islamic economic and legal history and an immensely well informed scholar. This latest work not only combines his earlier arguments but also provides some new perspectives.

The gist of Kuran’s arguments is the following (p. 281)
1. In its early centuries Islam developed a law of contracts that was sophisticated for the time.
2. This law allowed passive investors to shield their personal assets while … however, active partners carried full liability.
3. The death of a partner terminated the partnership automatically.
4. Due to the Islamic inheritance law and polygamy the numbers of heirs could be large.
5. The partnership termination rule, like the lack of entity shielding, discouraged the formation of large and long-lived partnerships. Successful businesses quickly disappeared and rarely survived the death of their founders.
6. The evolution from simple partnerships to the corporation never took place.
7. Thus several self-enforcing elements of Islamic law — contracts, inheritance system, marriage regulations — jointly contributed to the stagnation of the Middle East.

These, otherwise, persuasive arguments (items 2-6) have several weaknesses: First, they are theoretical and some of them are not correct. Take item 2: Active partners in a mudaraba partnership did not carry any pecuniary liability unless proven to have been negligent. Take item 3: In an inan partnership with three or more partners, the death of one of them did not lead to automatic termination of the partnership. So, if the partners wished their firms to have longevity, all they had to do was to establish an inan partnership with three colleagues. Take items 4 to 5: Polygamy and the Islamic law of inheritance certainly must have resulted in a large number of heirs. But primogeniture, much admired by Kuran, or primogeniture-like solutions, could be realized through hiba (inter vivos gifts) or establishing family waqfs.  Kuran recognizes the latter but dismisses the waqfs for being too rigid. In doing this, he ignores the “ten conditions” of the Hanefite law, which provided considerable flexibility to the waqf managers, as well as the possibility that the founder of a waqf could always have written a flexible deed to start with, if he so wished. The fact that many waqfs have survived for centuries may indicate that, indeed, they had flexible structures. Without a thorough and comparative analysis of the foundation deeds of waqfs, these institutions should not be dismissed so offhandedly.

Item 6 brings me to the second weakness: Though essentially correct — the evolution from simple partnerships to the business corporation, indeed, did not take place until the late nineteenth century, this failure was probably caused not by any failure or rigidity of the Islamic law but by other factors far more important than those mentioned by Kuran. In a nutshell, these factors were the following: geography, price and profit controls, high rates of interest (twice the permitted rates of profit), property rights restrictions, widespread confiscations and sustained crowding-out effects, in short, primarily the Ottoman “proto-quasi socialism.”[1] The relative power of the state, ever since Roman times, was of particular importance. Kuran recognizes that the European corporation flourished when central authority weakened following the demise of the Roman Empire (p. 103) but fails to contrast this with the situation in the Middle East, where the opposite was taking place and the region was militarizing in response to the Crusades. This failure is all the more striking because, based upon Shatzmiller, Kuran does provide his readers with excellent data on this phenomenon (p. 69).

So far, I have merely showed that Islamic law did provide sufficient flexibility to overcome the difficulties mentioned by Kuran. Interestingly, he is aware of some of these flexibilities (p. 80) but dismisses them. The question, however, remains whether Muslims actually made use of these. Did they, for instance, use the inan partnership with three partners in order to ensure longevity for their firms? Or, did they practice inter vivos gifts in order to protect the family property/firm from fragmentation? Such questions can only be answered by extensive research among the surviving records of the Islamic court registers. Kuran has mobilized a group of professional historians and had thousands of such cases transcribed. The results have been published in ten volumes. Although he deserves to be applauded for this effort, it is strange that he has provided such scant evidence for his arguments. There is no doubt that future historians will use his data as well as many others from among the more than 10,000 volumes of Istanbul court registers to test further.
This brings me to the most important weakness of this work. Kuran has reached a sensational conclusion with theoretical arguments supported by scant evidence. He has not hesitated to advertise his conclusion even in the very title of his book. He is so convinced of this conclusion that although throughout the book his readings clearly point to other possible causes, he has dismissed them.  Had he made these logical deductions, the title of his book might have been very different.

All in all, this is a most informative book, one which should be read, however, with a huge grain of salt due to its author’s commitment to discrediting Islamic law.

 

 

Roads to nowhere or bridges to growth: What do we know about public investment efficiency in developing countries?

Pritchett (2000) convincingly argued that the notion that public investment spending is equal to capital accumulation is a heroic assumption in many developing countries as public investment is not inherently productive. All too often, inefficiency, waste, or corruption, distort the impact of public spending on capital accumulation. Examples abound of unfinished roads leading to nowhere, incomplete bridges and power generation projects, and other white-elephant projects. Private investment returns, in turn, are lowered by the lack of complementary public inputs. Not surprisingly, the much anticipated growth dividends fail to materialise.

The Chinese Art of Elegant Bribery

The Chinese art of bribery

The Process of Elegant Bribery: Four Scenarios:

.. there are countless ways to bribe “elegantly” and “legitimately”. In the following, … four most common scenarios down:

The First Scenario:

The corrupted official can sell a fake painting at any rigged gallery. After coordinating with the official, the briber will go to the designated gallery and buy it at the agreed price plus the commission of the gallery owner. All of the three parties know that the painting is fake, but eventually they are all benefited. This fake painting can be reused and it can go through another bribery circulation of other “elegant” buyers and sellers.

The Second Scenario:

The briber puts a real and expensive painting at the gallery. The gallery marks down the price as if it were a fake painting. The official buys it as if he has the greatest bargain on earth. Sooner or later, the official can resell it at the right place, at the right time, and at the right price.

The Third Scenario:

The briber visits the official and gives him/her a real or fake painting as a present. Three days later, a seemingly unrelated person knocks the door of the official and buys that particular painting at an unreasonably high price. This buyer is actually a trusted subordinate of the briber, and, by doing so, the whole process does not involve the gallery whose owner will certainly ask for a commission.

The Fourth Scenario:

There are rigged auction houses all over China and they become the most suitable places for elegant corruption. The briber, first of all, gets a fake painting either from a gallery or a fake painting factory. Then, s/he provides relevant document proof of scholars and experts to take care of the problem of authenticity. These scholars and experts are paid to confirm the authenticity of this fake painting. They falsify every historical detail, evidence of painting style and scientific verification of the materials used. The forged painting is then given to the official as a gift and is auctioned at a very high price. Eventually, there is always someone coming from nowhere who wins the bid. Again, the bidder is a trusted person of the briber. These auction houses get hush money before the whole corruption process is completed.

 

Politicians’ salaries: Leaders of the fee world

From Economist.com

Country Basic Salary (PPP)
GDP/Capita(PPP) Ratio
kenya 427886 1730 247.33
singapore 2183516 50523 43.22
indonesia 124171 4157 29.87
south africa 272280 10244 26.58
hong kong 513245 42748 12.01
new zealand 271799 26708 10.18
france 302435 33679 8.98
united states of america 400000 46381 8.62
japan 273676 32608 8.39
germany 283608 34212 8.29
ireland 287900 39468 7.29
russia 115000 14920 7.71
australia 286752 38911 7.37
britain 215390 34619 6.22
taiwan 184200 31834 5.79
argentina 74126 14561 5.09
south korea 136669 27978 4.88
israel 120814 28393 4.26
canada 148209 38025 3.90
poland 45045 18072 2.49
china 10633 6567 1.62
india 4106 2941 1.40

How about Malaysia? (Figures are for 2009. Source-IMF)

PM Basic Salary=RM22800x12=RM273600
Malaysia’s GDP/Capita (PPP) = 13769
Malaysia’s GDP/Capita (Nominal) =USD6897
USD-MYS exchange Rate=3.5RM/USD
PM Basic Salary at PPP=(RM273600/3.5)x(13769/6897)=156030

Ratio of Leader’s Pay to GDP Per Capita = 156030/13769 = 11.3

What does it mean? The salary of US president is 8.6 times higher than US output per capita. Malaysia’s PM basic salary is 11.3 times larger than Malaysia’s output per capita.

How Islamic are Islamic Countries?

Rehman, Scheherazade S. and Askari, Hossein (2010) “How Islamic are Islamic Countries?,” Global Economy Journal: Vol. 10 : Iss. 2, Article 2.

“Our very preliminary results show that Islamic countries are not as Islamic in their practice as one might expect; instead it appears that the most developed countries tend to place higher on our preliminary IslamicityIndex.”(p.20)

Abstract:
In the post 9/11 era, there is growing interest in the complex relationship between religion, economics, finance, politics, law, and social behavior. This has brought with it a disagreement on how to investigate the impact of religiosity, whether religion affects the economic, political, and social outlook of countries or whether these factors affect religiosity? In other words, should religion be viewed as a dependent or an independent variable? In this paper we ask what we believe to be the precursor question to such linkages, namely, do self-declared Islamic countries, as attested by membership in the OIC (Organization of Islamic Conference), embrace policies that are founded on Islamic teachings? We believe that only once this question is addressed can one begin to estimate how Islam adherence to Islam may affect economic, political and social behavior. In the first part of the paper we present what we believe should be the characteristics and scaffolding of an “Islamic” country. We base our depiction on the Quran, and the life, practices and sayings of the Prophet Mohammad — the two principal channels that provide Muslims with the road map. In the second part, we develop an index to measure the “Islamicity” of Islamic and non-Islamic countries. This IslamicityIndex (or I2) measures 208 countries adherence to Islamic principles using four sub-indices related to economics, legal and governance, human and political rights, and international relations.

Malaysian Economic Monitor

In November 2009, the Government of Malaysia and the World Bank signed a three-year Partnership Agreement focused on the policy challenge of growing into a high-income economy.
The Malaysian Economic Monitor series is a key pillar in this Partnership and represents an effort to promote discussion, analysis, and the sharing of knowledge on the challenges ahead.

WAKE UP MALAYSIA; IT’S TIME TO PLAY THE ‘BEYOND GDP’ GAME!

The bulk of the discussions surrounding the recent announcements on the Malaysian Government’s economic strategies, such as the 10th Malaysia Plan and the New Economic Model, have been centered on the issue of high-income economy. To the discerning few, this situation raises a pertinent concern on whether or not high-income is necessarily good for the well being of all Malaysians in the spirit of 1Malaysia. Indeed, this is a valid reaction given that; as rightly pointed out by many segments of the society who have commented on those announcements, the actual thrust for those plans is the rakyat’s quality of life. Hence, in the absence of the most complete and universally accepted measure of overall quality of life, should we then allow GDP to be the irrefutable link to prosperity and progress even when the ‘father of GDP’, Simon Kuznet, himself admitted that GDP was never meant to be a measure for welfare and well-being? In other words, should we continue to feel comfortable with the skewed pursuit of economic growth especially when we are more than aware that economics is merely one of the various spheres in life?

It is taught in economics classes that GDP is simply an index of a country’s entire output; nothing more and nothing less. Its specific components, construct, computation and flaws are fully deliberated and thoroughly discussed to ensure that it is absolutely clear to the students of economics that GDP and its variants, for that matter; are strictly a bunch of not-so-full proof economic measures that acts as a general guide for policy makers. To shed light on the preceding point, it is just absurd to accept that expenditures on pollution clean-up, that go through the proper market channels like the ongoing desperate exercise along Louisana coast caused by the recent BP oil spill disaster, would actually contribute positively to the US GDP; whereas, the loss of wildlife and other environmental damages are completely ignored. Furthermore, that it is a measure devoid of other domains, for instance social, psychological, and spiritual, is well-known to the numerous civil society groups whose raison d’etre are concerns that surpass economics. Nonetheless, majority are still bewitched by the beauty of GDP for reasons which are less than convincing to the increasing many. Therefore; the critical question to the general public is; don’t we want to be free from this unintended spell, for our own and our future generation’s sake?

As a start, the rakyat should be enlightened on the notion that GDP must cease being the surrogate for quality of life. In fact, there exist a lot of other indicators used by supranational entities, governments, and local councils throughout the world to measure the true level of wellbeing for their diverse constituents. For one, the UN’s Human Development Index (HDI) that takes into account income, education, and health has been there for the past 20 years. In terms of coverage, HDI would surely serve as a much-improved reference benchmark than GDP. However, HDI still lacks the objective and holistic features for it to be the best measure of social progress. Despite this sorry state of HDI, the noble idea behind its birth has actually been embraced, extended, and applied by more and more countries.

Among the developed nations, Canada; which is a G7 and G20 member country, seems to be leading the pack by the official commencement of the initiative referred as the Canadian Index of Wellbeing (CIW) that garners the expertise of the Canadian government agencies, non-governmental organizations and universities. To these direct contributing parties; good living standards, robust health, a sustainable environment, vital communities, an educated populace, balanced time use, high levels of democratic participation, and access to and participation in leisure and culture; is what quality of life is all about. These ideal pictures of national happiness are encapsulated in the eight domains of wellbeing; namely, Education, Environment, Democratic Engagement, Living Standards, Healthy Populations, Time Use, Leisure and Culture, and Community Vitality. And by the end of this year, CIW will be published for the consumption of primarily the people of Canada to realign domestic political discourse and direction of public policy; better assess policy options and solutions, and more importantly, to hold decision makers directly accountable for the actual movements in what really matters to the Canadians.

As a consequence from feeling the heat of living in this age of turbulence, the US is also adopting this paradigm shift. In February 2003, the Government Accountability Office in partnership with the National Academy of Sciences acted upon this positive shift by convening a forum to create a national system of indicators that helps ordinary Americans to better assess for themselves the position and progress of their beloved nation. From such earlier efforts, The State of the USA or SUSA was institutionalized in 2007 to operate as a non-profit, non-partisan and tax-exempt entity. Working within the boundaries of Key National Indicators Act 2008, SUSA has been entrusted to come up with a Key National Indicator System that would measure and factually present the country’s most pressing issues for the policy makers to address them in a more coherent, consistent and concerted manner. This exemplary development underlines the seriousness in efforts to dethrone GDP even in this economic super power’s own backyard.

Not surprisingly, the interest on this ‘new game’ has gone across the Atlantic Ocean. The European Commission, European Parliament, Club of Rome, OECD, and WWF jointly organized the inaugural “Beyond GDP” Conference in November 2007. Its single most important objective was to settle the issue of which indices are most appropriate to measure progress so that they could best be integrated into Europe-wide public debate and decision-making process. As a follow-up to that ground-breaking event, a policy paper “GDP and beyond: Measuring progress in a changing world” was communicated in EU Roadmap 2009. That important document was prepared based on the premise that GDP must be complemented with environmental and social indicators to better measure progress. Quite similar to CIW, it was put forward in the paper that quality of life is reflected by indicators of income, public service, health, leisure, wealth, mobility, and a clean environment combined. Evidently, this scenario clearly highlights that the tides of change have also reached the shores of Europe.

In final analysis, the real catch-up game that our policy makers should be concentrating on is: how well we are doing on a more proper wellbeing or quality of life scale rather than the no longer trusted pseudo-measure, GDP. Yes, their preoccupation with the ‘old game’ would certainly lead us to be superficially happy enjoying the endless array of products and services that the market can perpetually offer. But unfortunately, at the same time, we would be feeling truly envious to the citizens of those other countries, whose policy makers have long started playing and thus, mastered this ‘new game’ which may be simply called the ‘Beyond GDP’ game.

On the part of the general public, let us have a consensus on the proposition that we have to stop playing the ‘old game’. To prevent from being trapped in that outdated game, it is imperative for us all to sincerely contemplate upon what really matters in life. Related to this point, Joseph E. Stiglitz; winner of 2001 Nobel Prize in Economics, lays down a very practical guiding principle in his latest book entitled Freefall; “what you measure is what you value, and vice versa”. Think long and hard on this philosophical issue and chances are; everyone would come to his or her senses.

Therefore, it is an opportune time for our country to be smart, proactive; hence, committed to this new game. The confidence and optimism to succeed is always high for majority of Malaysians sincerely believe that our beloved country does have the right resources, talents, and spirit to be a strong contender; if not the winner, in this ‘Beyond GDP’ game. Only then, the rakyat would be genuinely appreciative towards the various efforts undertaken by the democratically-elected government to improve their quality of life.

DR. MOHD MAHYUDI MOHD YUSOP
ISLAMIC ECONOMICS & POLICY RESEARCH UNIT
KULLIYYAH OF ECONOMICS AND MANAGEMENT SCIENCES
INTERNATIONAL ISLAMIC UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA